Thursday, March 3, 2011

Heritage Fair Judging Material and Grading Outlines

ACCUMULATED POINTS

Display Board
_____Points X4= ________/16
Artifacts/AV/Costume (etc)
_____Points X3= ________/**   
Content
_____Points X6= ________/24
Bibliography
_____Points X1= ________/3
Speech
_____Points X2= ________/8
Questions/Interview
_____Points X3= ________/12
 TOTAL
                             _______/63


DISPLAY BOARD
Demonstrates 1 or less of the 4 items listed below       1             Demonstrates 2 of the 4 items listed below   2
Demonstrates 3 of the 4 items listed below                   3             Demonstrates 4 of the 4 items listed below   4
·         High levels of creativity and imagination are seen in how the board is presented. 
·         Good use of colour.  Use of colour enhances the written work.
·         Panels are easy to read.  Aesthetically pleasing.
·         Use of pictures
COMMENTS: _____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
ARTIFACTS/AUDIO-VISUAL/COSTUME/MODELS (etc)        **BONUS
1                                    2                                     3                                    4
COMMENTS: _____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________
CONTENT
Demonstrates 1 of the 4 items listed below                   1             Demonstrates 2 of the 4 items listed below   2
Demonstrates 3 of the 4 items listed below                   3             Demonstrates 4 of the 4 items listed below   4
·         Has a minimum of 7 paragraphs related to the main topic.
·         The paragraphs are all relevant to one topic and provide an in depth description of what the topic is about.
·         There is mention of the historical importance of the topic.
·         Grammatically there are five or fewer errors noticed (spelling, punctuation, capitalization)
COMMENTS:
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Shows 1 reference              1             Shows 2 references            2             Shows 3 or more references             3

SPEECH
Demonstrates 1 of the 4 items listed below                   1             Demonstrates 2 of the 4 items listed below   2
Demonstrates 3 of the 4 items listed below                   3             Demonstrates 4 of the 4 items listed below   4
·         Speaks with a clear voice with appropriate volume and speed.
·         Maintains eye contact, and shows enthusiasm.
·         Explains personal or Canadian connection to topic.
·         Provides 3 key facts on topic.
 COMMENTS: _____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________




1
2
3
4
Questions/Interview
(Student(s) are to answer 2-3 questions, chosen by the judges). 
Answers 1 of 2 questions.

Has a difficult time explaining ideas.


Answers both questions, but with minimal detail.

Needs prompts to help guide in answering questions.
Answers both questions with some degree of detail.

Demonstrates moderate knowledge of topic.

A good, average answer.

Answers both questions with detailed answers.

Demonstrates extensive knowledge of topic.

No hesitations in answering questions.



COMMENTS: _____________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________

POSSIBLE JUDGES QUESTIONS (ask any 2)

Ø Why did you choose this topic for your project?
Ø How does your project relate to Canadian history?
Ø What was the one “WOW” moment you had while completing this project?  What really made you stop and think?
Ø After going through the whole research process, what is the one item you would change/do differently to enhance your project and why?
Ø What one thing did you learn most about Canada?
Ø What was the most challenging part of completing the project?

No comments:

Post a Comment